Nathan Thornburgh is the Brian Fantana of dadbloggers. When he’s not out travelling the globe, having adventures, and recording those adventures on the excellent site Roads And Kingdoms, he’s wryly observing Dad Culture on the also-excellent site DadWagon (and I hate to play favorites, but I’ll say it – DadWagon has been my favorite dad site for some time now). We’re stoked to have him contribute this post, and hope that it helps you avoid being pegged as a paederast. - Jason
I have lots of problems. Let’s talk about one of them: I am a bad listener. In one small example of this, I have not been listening very closely to the Internet lately, so I missed this entire conversation that happened almost a month ago. But it’s a good conversation, and something that dads can contribute to mightily (as opposed, say, to conversations about which breast pads work best).
It is, of course, the heaping pile of paranoia that Circle of Moms contributor Sharon Silver posted in her piece called “How To Spot A Child Predator”. If you, like me, haven’t been paying attention, let me summarize: concerned mom walks into a sandwich shop and sees an older man having an animated conversation (about astronomy, in part) with two 3rd graders, so she goes up to the counter of the shop, essentially calls him a pedophile in a loud voice, and then walks out proudly to go blog about it.
I don’t want to lay into Mrs. Silver personally, since I have no idea if she is that immoderate in the rest of her life or writing. And I really appreciate her candor. Blogging is supposed to be all personal and expressive, but many of us (I’m guilty of this) pull our punches and self-censor when we write. That’s a shame: we end up presenting a carefully stylized version of ourselves and our thoughts, versions that are inevitably safer, more normative, less outrageous than we really are. Silver does not have that problem. She initiates what I would consider to be an unfortunate fit of slanderous fingerpointing in a public place and she has the strength (or lack of filter) to just present it all from her unique point of view.
Did I say unique? One of the reasons that I am so drawn to the post is that I don’t think she’s very unique at all. She is just more open about it. Really, I think many consumers of mass media in this country could be forgiven for thinking that this is what pedophilia looks like: a conversation in a public place between a man and children he’s not related to. Silver uses language that you’re likely to hear on any evening newscasts, especially during sweeps season:
My name is being called to pick up my sandwich. Then, like a thunderbolt, it hits me! Those boys are being groomed. That man may be a predator!
This is not a gender thing per se. The messaging in our country—be afraid—is powerful enough to blast through chromosomal differences. The comments section in Silver’s post, which is now closed, included plenty of women who pointed out there is, in the words of one commenter, “a whole lot of crazy going on in this ‘article’”.
But since this is 30 days of dadbloggers here at DadCentric, I think it’s worth pointing out that there were NO men (that I saw at least) supporting the public shaming of a dude for essentially being a dude and talking to children. But even more than that, the dadblogosphere did a nice step further and explained why Silver’s reaction was not just wrong, but even damaging. Zach Rosenberg over at 8BitDads (who apparently took astronomy at UC Santa Cruz like I did) wrote a nice piece pointing out how dangerous Silveresque hysteria is to the already frail sense of community we have in this country. BloggerFather did his first xtranormal video on the topic, in which he was able to just use Silver words verbatim and that was all the comedy needed.
I can’t improve on their sentiments, but I can say that my job now involves me getting into situations that would put me perhaps in this poor sandwich shop dude’s shoes. That is, I travel, and I talk to, and take pictures of, strangers. Sometimes children even, if they are around and part of the story I’m working on. This could land me in trouble, for example, with pro-Silver commenter Michelle, who asked over at Circle of Moms, “if you see a man surreptitiously taking pictures of a child (say, a little girl around the age of 7 or 8) with whom he is clearly not familiar, do you assume it's all ‘harmless’?” I rely very much on the fact that in other countries, I haven’t run into the kind of rich, dark imagination that Michelle has. People may or may not like me taking pictures, and I never do it surreptitiously, but never has it come up that I might be some kind of child predator.
The key thing is that I, like the dadbloggers I mentioned, will read Silver’s post or future posts like them and immediately identify with the hounded man, not with Silver. As dads get more involved as parents, we’re going to be the ones who watch over and take care of our own kids, and in a pinch, other people’s kids. If the dominant voices out there say “fear men”, then it’s even more important that people are out keep writing as fathers, not predators, explaining that some men think children are actually interesting to talk to, with their anarchic minds and sense of wonder. And maybe we’ll get the Sharon Silvers of the world to think twice before turning a trip to the mall into an episode of Law & Order: SVU.
So get out there and blog, dammit. That guy in the sandwich shop needs you.
Recent Comments